Rated 2.3 out of 5 by 23
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by RenoDIY Never Dry
I needed a wood filler (nail holes) for my bathroom cabinets. This Painter's Putty was recommended. After filling numerous holes and 36 hours later (Warm sunny days in SoCal), the putty never dried.
I tried scraping this stuff off. When sanding, the putty just clogged up sheets of sandpaper.
This is terrible stuff or I was sold the wrong item. Caution: You will need a magnifying glass to read the directions on the container!
September 3, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by jj TERRIBLE
This was recommended to me by the HD Pro(no) desk who said just slap your last coat of paint on after it dries and your done. . I painted my trim prior to installing now I have to go through the entire house with oil base paint and go over every nail hole. Then I can paint you know if it ever dries fully.
April 20, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Flip JUNK!
BEWARE! This stuff is garbage! Read the fine print on back (the writing is 1\16 big) 2 week dry time and cannot be sanded. I have a disaster on all my new trim in the whole house! No where on the front label says oil based. Whoever invented this stuff needs to be fired!
December 20, 2015
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Robo Not what I was expecting
This product is very thick. So thick I couldn't really use the putty knife to smack on the wall. Takes 48 hours to dry.
August 31, 2015
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by southplank Make sure this is what you need...
I really hated this stuff. Mainly because it was suggested to me as better than Spackle. If your application would benefit from a putty, then this is for you. It is a linseed oil based putty pretty much identical to glazier putty. You can shape it, stuff it somewhere and smooth it, but don't expect it to work nice and thin like regular Spackle. If you are fixing small cracks, scratches or very tiny depressions, stick to spackling compound. This stuff will just aggravate you for delicate sheet rock repairs. I think this would work well on exterior wood imperfections before painting or replacing glass in an old single pane window.
August 26, 2014
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by DIYinOH Impossible to work with.
This is the consistency of silly putty (hence the name), which makes it really really hard to work with. It won't spread with a knife. It takes 7+ days to fully dry/cure. It leaves your hands and the surface oily. It can't be sanded.
I'm REALLY struggling to find a use for this stuff. Run of the mill patch filler works 100 times better, 10 times faster, and is just as cheap.
I tried to fill some large holes with the putty, planning on a small once over with joint compound to smooth it out... but it never really cured after 5 days. So I had to scrape it all out and stuff the hole with joint compound anyways.
I would avoid this one.
December 31, 2013
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by DonP Label Very Misleading
The front label says "for filling nail holes, dents and cracks in wood surfaces". This product is not sand-able in 48 hours. I was expecting to be able to sand in a reasonable drying time. The front label says "exceptional paintability". The back label In the very small print that I needed a magnifying glass to read says paintable with latex based paint. But to read on you find out that you have to prime it first with an oil base paint.
April 17, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by SteveVA Great for cracks and holes
I used this putty to repair drywall cracking I get in my house when the temperature changes. I also used it to fill-in and repair holes from a flat-screen TV hangar I had installed. I have used other messy fillers before and like the putty the best. It is easy to prepare, manipulate and clean-up is a cinch. Its thickness is a major factor. Smoothing it over with a scraper was easy and their was no messy leftovers.
After letting it dry for 48 hours I noticed no shrinkage and the paint applied and dried well.
I will always keep some of this on hand for small drywall repairs and highly recommend it to other homeowners.
December 21, 2013