Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 42
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by Josh The supports are tricky
I didn't realize until I tried to assemble them that the vertical supports come in two pieces. Since I didn't have help to assemble them, this was a logistical challenge. What saved the day was using quick release clamps to brace the two vertical supports together using a third support aligned with them temporarily. Then I was able to lean the partially assembled frame up against a wall and install the horizontal supports that braced the vertical supports. The I removed the clamps and continued with the assembly. VERY poor design, splitting the vertical supports in two pieces like that. Once they are assembled, the shelves are fine, but they make it WAY more challenging to assemble than they need to.
September 1, 2015
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by Mike Good, but with one significant flaw
I bought two of these shelves for storage in my garage.
I didn't realize that the uprights were half height when I ordered, so each shelf unit is essentially two units that stack on top of each other. It would be easier to provide one piece uprights (the box is that long anyway) and it would make the shelves much sturdier.
The shelves went together relatively easily. I had to use pliers to unbend some slightly bent brackets, and one shelf didn't fit quite right, but was quickly fixed. I'm concerned about the long term ability of the particle board shelves to not sag under load.
I would give these shelves nearly five stars if the uprights had been one piece.
September 2, 2011
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by jcm1 Poor design for assembly
Haven't had a chance to use this product and it may be very sturdy once assembled. However, in order to save money (I assume), the upright supports for the 72"H unit come in 2 pieces each instead of 1 long piece. This makes assembly very difficult as it is hard to keep the unit squared while assembling. If the uprights were each a single piece, it would be much easier to put together. I'm assuming the manufacturer did this in order to use the same pieces for both taller and shorter units, but it makes it difficult for the end user to put together. I'm assuming if you have one of the shorter units that requires only a single upright, it would be much easier to assemble.
August 14, 2011
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by mrdisappointed dont waste your time
Approx half of the parts fit together, the other half wasnt even close. Colossal waste of my time
May 21, 2016
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by Yossarian Not recommended
As mentioned by others, the four support bars that form the corners are actually 8 bars--a bottom half and an upper half. They are connected at the middle by the middle shelf and that is all. I suppose it was stable enough, but it was hardly comforting. Once the unit was put together (about an hour using three people to stabilize the various connecting pieces) the entire unit was uneven and flimsy in appearance. Had no desire to entrust storing multiple supplies on it, much less building the other five units that had been purchased. Also, the wood that's provided as the actual shelving is flimsy. I would recommend a complete re-design by the company, but the at the very least they could provide some kind of supports to slide underneath the shelving to support the middle areas to prevent future sagging.
September 16, 2014
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Bob12005 Great shelving!
Shelving is of good quality and easy to assemble. Would buy tem again.
December 9, 2015
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by JCros disappointing change in design
Previously this type of shelving was available with 7-foot posts, which are very strong indeed. The present design (6-foot posts made of two 3-foot pieces) is significantly weaker and more difficult to assemble besides. The only clear benefit to the shorter "modular" design is that it's easier to ship. The inclusion of a bracket or brace to join the two pieces into one post would mitigate this bad design change.
March 12, 2013
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by AMICHIGANBUYER FAILED HOME DEPOST OF MICHIGAN SALES OPERATIONS RELEASEING INCOMPLETE SHELF
THE PINS THAT HOLD THE SHELFS DO NOT SIT ALL THE WAY DOWN WITH THE WEIGHT ON THE SHELF WITH THE HD EMPLOYEES ASSEMBLY .
THE COMPANY EDSAL FAILED TO PROPERLY PAINT THE SHELF WITH THE PRIMER PAINT SHOWING THROUGH .
THE EDSAL COMPANY NEGLIGENT IN TESTING AND BUILDING TO PLACE THE PINS IN THE RIGHT LOCATIONS TO HOLD THE SHELF TOGETHER.
THIS IS A TWO PIECE SHELF POLE SUPPORTS.
THIS MODEL DOES NOT COME WITH ONE POLE DESIGN TO HOLD SHELFS .
HOME DEPOST DID A POOR SALES JOB WORKING WITH EDSAL
June 24, 2015