Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 16
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by luann good standard
This is a rather old fashioned option I chose, because of its self draining design and unlike modern options of glass or marble that seem dangerous to me.
July 5, 2016
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Mariajdav Beautiful and functional
I bought two of these and they look great with my white and blue tiles.
August 16, 2015
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by clydebob not what i expected
the shelves were not smooth on the edges facing the tile wall so i couldn't use them. i'm still looking for a replacement
April 12, 2016
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by JMark235 Good quality but more difficult to install than need be.
As this piece was designed for installation in tile rather than a flush mount, there are projections on the back to which the thin set is applied with the projections going into the gap made by cutting the tile to fit the piece. Each of the 2 sides requires a different tile cutout measurement (about 6.75" on one side and 7" on the other) - it would be easier if they required the same measurement. Also, because the projections extend so far to the front, the cutout needs to be particularly precise to avoid the corners of the cutout from being noticeable from the front of the finished job. The projections on the back could have ended 1/4" more from the end of the sides without compromising strength and it would have made the installation much easier & fool proof. Remember when calculating your cutout measurements to compensate for the cutout in the tile on the 1st wall tile you install in the corner.
The piece is otherwise well designed. It has a pitch builtin so water will drain from the shelf without having to angle the piece when installing it. You might want to angle the piece slightly when installing to enable water on the upper grout line to drain.I dropped 1 about 3 feet onto a tile floor and it was undamaged.
Note that there aren't any installation instructions in or on the package.
February 15, 2016
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Lstone Tile Shelf
We liked these selves but had to return them. We found out that not all WHITE is the same. Our white subway tile came from a different manufacturer so these did not match. Although we liked the design of these shelves better we had to go back and order shelves from the same company as the tiles. Lesson learned there. Nice product though!
December 22, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by 1968mo Replacement caddies
These are a replacement for a pair of 15 year old brass shower caddies. It was the closest match to our marble bathroom and for the price it was a great choice. We have very hard water and I did not want to put brass in again; besides the fact that brass is very difficult to find. They look clean and they do the job, so I am very satisfied. You just need someone who knows how to install in a pre-existing tiled shower.
December 29, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Handy Just what I needed
Needed to replace a broken shelf, one of two that were installed several years ago when the shower was remodeled; while this purchase was not an exact match to the remaining good one (I was not able to find the exact shelf anywhere), it was close enough in size/style to suit our purposes. Shelf appears to be of good quality -- just finished installing it a few days ago. I rated the ease of installation only a 3 not because there is anything wrong with the shelf, but because you need to have the right tools/skill to replace a shelf like this. I was able to use an oscillating tool with a carbide tip blade to cut out the remaining pieces of the broken shelf and remove the old adhesive. Then, because this new shelf was not an exact match to the old one, I had to enlarge the opening in the tile shower wall to accept the new shelf -- again I carefully used the oscillating tool and carbide tipped blade to gently cut the tile, without chipping/breaking the tiles in the area. A 2x4 propped under the shelf to the floor, and duct tape to hold the shelf in place while the adhesive dried, did the trick. Of course, the job was not completed until I caulked all necessary areas around the new shelf. Very pleased with final results and look.
November 12, 2014
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Jay45238 Badly Out of Square
Not sure if it is a manufacturing defect or what, but so out of square that it took a TON of caulk to make it even look close to right...
January 15, 2014