Rated 3.5 out of 5 by 33
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Buyer FADING CUSHIONS; Didn't last one season
I purchased 6 of these chairs last spring. They came with Orange cushions that are now close to white due to fading by the sun. They are not even a year old and replacement cushions are not available.
April 13, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by DAVINALV REPLACEMENT OUTDOOR CHAIR CUSHIONS
We went ahead & ordered 2 replacements cushions (2 of ours were already showing sun fade badly) not knowing if the product would be available next season. I noticed that the store were no longer carrying the set. We purchased the entire set consisting of sofa, 2 chairs, 1 rocker swivel chair, coffee table & 3 end tables. It will be a shame if this set is discontinued for what I paid & replacement cushions, etc. aren't available in the future. We really enjoy the Martha Stewart Charlotteown Cpllection.
Las Vegas, Nevada
August 19, 2014
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by Faded FADED
Cushions faded in just one season with only indirect sunlight.
May 10, 2015
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by Pause Cushions and material poor quality
We love the Charlottetown furniture purchased may 2014; however, the quality of the internal cushion material as well as the covers is very poor. In less than 1 month the cushions were collapsing after less than 1 hour of sitting and they did not bounce back! Also the seams of the cover material were loosely sewn (based) with material that frays easily. Cheaply made product. Basic stitching teachings knows such material needs to be zigzagged to prevent unraveling. Warranty is just a word and does not reflect quality.
We cannot use the purchased cushions due to their breakdown. Now in order to enjoy our porch furniture a year later we have to purchase new cushions.
May 20, 2015
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by NrseNncy Fades Horribly in One Season
I purchased this expensive set and the first season on my back patio it faded HORRIBLY. Looks terrible and replacement cushions are nearly the price of the whole chair new! Terrible product, terrible value and should not carry the Martha Stewart name which used to indicate quality. I live in Washington state where we have very little sunny days so this should never have faded so much in one summer. Now I am stuck with a terrible looking patio set because I cannot afford to replace this whole set with new cushions every year. Save your money unless you have an inside covered patio/porch.
May 27, 2015
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by islandtime Quality product wrong color
This product was advertised as Quarry Red. However, the product upon delivered was rust/orange in color, make sure the actual color will work with your color scheme. The product is good quality and superior to the original cushions
March 25, 2015
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by MassResidemt Comfortable but fades
If the furniture is going to be outside I would suggest not buying it or getting covers or taking the cushions in when not in use. If they will be sheltered and in the shade then I would buy these again. The furniture pieces are bulky so they won't fit in a tight spot. The material of the chair itself is sturdy and has held up very nicely in two years of use. The cushions on the other hand are not durable. The fabric is tough but it faded dramatically in three months in Massachusetts weather. They were originally a orange color (not the red the manufacturer claims) but now they are a fading shades of a sunset from Orange to peach to almost white. Replacement cushions are $79.00 for a chair that's $129.00 to purchase new. I am considering using fabric spray paint to breathe color back in these as the cushion itself is still firm and has several more years of life left in it. As for comfort for the chairs most people who have used them Need a pillow to sit. The base is very deep and the lumbar support is extremely lacking. A pillow is a must. Oddly enough my pillows haven't faded in the four years I have had them compared to these cushions.
May 25, 2015
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by littlesisterbell Fabric faded quickly
I bought 4 rockers and a coffee table. Only used part of summer and the orange fabric faded very noticeably. The rockers and table are great quality but when you pay $80 a per chair to replace the cushions only to have them fade again, this proves very costly. And makes the set a poor buy.
April 23, 2014