Rated 3.0 out of 5 by 17
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Halo23 Color faded fast
Purchased the whole Martha Stewart outdoor furniture set that had this type cushions. Within in a year the cushions badly faded bleached out. Then they seemed to continue to fade stored indoors out of the sun over the winter. Initially they were very comfortable and we liked them. However the color faded fast within one season. We were very disappointed in the overall poor quality for the fabric on these cushions. We expected more since they had the Martha Stewart brand!
May 15, 2016
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by PhxPhade Faded material
Though the love-seat, end table, and small coffee table are sturdy and look nice, the cushions have faded dramatically in less than one year. Most of the time the furniture was in shade but in Phoenix, a little sun goes a long way. I am online trying to purchase replacement cushions but after reading that others are having the same trouble, I think the manufacturer should consider a do-over!
In addition, I don't want replacement cushions that are going to fade again AND is stated to be thinner and of less quality. I would think the Martha Stewart brand would want to rectify.
May 21, 2016
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by LexKYCat Very good purchase!
I purchased the Charlottetown set, ie 2 chairs, loveseat, and ottoman(table) 3 years ago and was extremely please with the set. This set is in our condo in Myrtle Beach SC in our rental unit. It held up very well, however over the 3 winters the cushion were fading quite a bit, so we needed to replace. I was very reluctant to order the replacement cusions based on the other reviews. Much to my wonderful surprise, they are exactly as the original. Not sure why others may have received less quality or different product. I live in KY so they were shipped here. Perhaps it is different depending on which state you live in, or better said, where the cushions are shipped from. Also, delivery was prompt. Scheduled delivery was March 24 and I received on March 11th!
March 14, 2016
Rated 2.0 out of 5.0 by DL Charlottetown Quarry Red Loveseat Replacement Cushion
These replacements are of less quality then the originals. There is not a zipper provided on the over of the back cushion to remove them for cleaning as on origanals. The lining of the original cushions disintegrated it was so cheap. We were unable to remove the covers for cleaning without causing interior batting to be destroyed. That is why replacements were required. The replacement linings are of even less quality. Also, the cover color originally purchased was no longer available to fit our first purchase. We will be re-upholstering the linings of both set of cushions and have superior products that will not need to be replaced. We also purchased replacement cushions for outdoor glider/rocker for the same reasons. Received the same poor replacement cushions.
February 24, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Mikey Poor construction and look cheap
Construction and look cheap. Would not order again nor would I recommend to anyone
December 13, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Summertime Great Purchase
This ended up being a great purchase. I was a little worried based on other reviews about the quality compared to the originals, however everything was just as good. Cushions were firm, fabric color bright. I am very happy with this purchase and would purchase again if needed. Made my set look brand new after two years. I wish the fabric did not fade as quickly on the originals in the 2 years I had them and hope these will last a little longer, that would be the only negative but I will be trying to add a UV protection to them and use more cover up.
June 16, 2015
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by NrseNncy Fades Horribly!
I purchased a full set of this Martha Stewart patio set in the quarry red and the first summer it faded HORRIBLY. I live in Washington state where we receive very little sun and now it looks terrible. A very pricey set for such poor quality. The Martha Stewart name should not be on this poor product. The cost to replace all of these cushions are exorbitant and nearly the price of buying the whole set new! Do not buy this set unless you have a covered inside patio/porch area because it does not last. Extremely disappointing.
May 27, 2015
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by KatyMom Better than the original cushions
The color is orange. Not red. Which I am happy about because they were purchased the replace the original orange cushions of the same brand. However, they made the fabric tougher and left off the buttons this time. On the old cushions, in order to wash the slip covers (which were able to be unzipped), you had to cut off the decorative button and you couldn't put them back on. I guess they learned from that since most people like to wash their outdoor cushions and left them off this time. Definitely a great replacement cushion in a beautiful color.
December 10, 2014