Rated 3.3 out of 5 by 50
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by PJW1976 Good Set, but some issues
This dining set is OK, but some things to be aware of:
1. The table top is made of "Weather Stone", essentially a kind of poured, formed concrete. It is likely to have some minor cracks due to shipping. Ours had some small cracks along the edges and bottom. The set comes with touch-up paint, which easily fixes the problem if it is not too sever.
2. Like other concrete products, you may get some efflorescence (white powdery substance) when the table surface gets very wet. It is also quite heavy.
3. The chairs are very light weight & are only rated to support 250 lbs.
4. The lumbar pillow tends to slip between the seat cushion and chair back.
August 7, 2012
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by Zia007 Quite the Assembly Project but Good Quality Stuff!
"Some assembly required" is what we've all heard and laughed about. These chairs and tables are pretty good quality stuff but the assembly is a bigger project than you might expect. The table is quite heavy and solid (good thing) but takes a fair amount of strength to get everything to line up and tighten up.
The design structurally is good on the table and reasonable on the chairs. I'm over 200 lbs and they hold me fine but I hesitate to lean back too aggressively. The bar that spans under the seat allows some flex (feels almost like a slight rocker) but is actually the metal flexing. I worry that after a while of flexing it may fatigue and break. So far it seems to be holding just fine!
August 21, 2012
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by hemoelaine The Martha Stewart dining set Sea Bright is a very nice set, comfortable and reasonably priced.
The dining set was easy to assemble and was delivered undamaged. I did have some trouble tracking my purchase online. Each of 3 reps from Home Depot gave me 3 different delivery dates which ranged from 6 days after purchase ( which was incorrect) to " it is just arriving from overseas and will be delivered some time next week" ( which was also wrong). I was VERY pleased that a customer service rep adjusted my purchase price when I noticed online that the price had dropped $50 since my transastion was made. Overall, quite a good experience with Home Depot online .
July 24, 2012
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Lala I wouldn't recommend this product to anyone
We are v. dissapointed w/ this item. The table is v. dark (wasn't evident on HD picture) That, I can accept but not the scratches and the chips/dents on the table -- it doesn't look good at all and doesn't even look new. We are still in the process of putting the chairs together-not sure how they'll come out. The only nice thing about the set are the cushions -(which can be replaced anyway unlike the table) - I cannot believe that Martha Stewart put out such a poor product - is she and HD aware how bad this is? HD delivery was on time and was satisfactory.
August 9, 2012
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by Northwest Nice looking, but...
This is a decent set, but a few words of caution. When it ships, check the table top thoroughly. Ours was full of cracks and chips. Home depot hooked us up with the manufacturer and they replaced it. The chairs do NOT rock. They swivel but are not fitted with hardware to rock. I bought this set based on the swivel rocker chairs. I informed them of this, and they refunded me 10% or optioned me to return the set. You will never get this thing boxed back up...I took the 10%. The backs on the chair do not go low enough to keep the cute little yellow pillow from squirting out the back of the chair when you sit in it. And finally, wait for the big closeout sale at the end of the year to buy. We bought it when it was 10% off, it became MUCH cheaper near the end of the season.
March 18, 2012
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by PamR GORGEOUS! AND DURABLE!
We purchased this sea bright set for our dining room... I have grandkids and did not want a wood set. I love it !
its not only a gorgeous set, its sturdy . It was very easy to put together. I did it myself... the cushions are a beautiful nutmeg color and the lumbar pillows are a very nice match! The weatherstone table top is what really sold me... its really a beautful design and the table is very sturdy ! The chairs are very comfortable...
we are hoping to purchase additional back cushions
for the chairs....
June 26, 2012
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by mantn Disappointed
Was very disappointed in the quality of the chairs as one was broken when received. They are extremely light-weight, which is great if you need to move them frequently; however I believe this is also the reason it was already broken. There was also a crack across the entire bottom part of the tabletop. Customer service was willing to replace the tabletop, but when the chair was also discovered broken, it changed our minds about keeping the set. We loaded it up and took the entire set back to the store for refund.
July 17, 2012
Rated 3.0 out of 5.0 by TexasSunshine Very Nice-Looks great on the screen porch.
Assembly required was not that hard, but a little time consuming. One of the attachments on the bottom of the table that the legs bolt to broke off - a trip to Home Depot for some gorrilla glue did the trick. This dining set was not my first pick, I pick out a dining set on line that had seat and back cushions, but it was no longer available, so this was my second choice. I am glad we only paid $399.00 for this, as it is not worth $699.00. Loved the FREE SHIPPING.
July 31, 2012