Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 214
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Dissapointed This is a great idea. Reusable, compressible, and easy to install......however IT DOES NOT WORK. I removed a toilet to remove a tile floor in preparation to install a wood floor. Knowing that I would have to remove this toilet in a month this seemed ideal. In the very short period of time this was installed it delaminated and failed. The interior of this seal is essentially a kitchen sponge. It became completely saturated with fluid. To all of the reviewers who are positive on the qualities of this product I am with you except...have you looked at this after being in service? Just because it is easy to install does not mean that it will actually work. I contacted customer service and was told they are aware of this problem and wanted me to ship them this seal and send a replacement. Have not heard back from them so I assume they were not really interested. Anyway who would want a replacement for a product you can't trust. Folks....stay away from this item. There are more reliable products.
October 27, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by DIYDude Unfortunately It Didn't Work Well and Needs Improvement to Lamination
I really wanted to like it but it just didn't work well. Installed it and noticed a smell and leaking from it right away. Then re-installed and checked it a few months later. There were the tell-tale stains.
It also de-laminated in some minor spots but who knows how this would hurt it over time. I even inspected a brand new Sani-Seal and noticed that it was not 100% perfectly laminated from the factory. It had weak spots that you can see if you look at it closely. Does this hurt the seal? I don't know, but it doesn't give much confidence either.
It's possible in my situation that it required doubling up the number of Sani-seals since my flange was below the floor. I'll never know because I used another wax-less seal made by Korky and that did the trick with no problems.
August 25, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Bowchie "Will not deteriorate" is a complete misstatement
I used this for less than 1 year on a toilet which I recently decided to replace with a new low volume model. I was quite surprised to see what had happened to this in a short time. It is a good idea and is easy to use but the foam covering completely disintegrates and the foam inside becomes open to the hard water/toilet cleaning chemicals etc. I can only wonder what would have been left if the old toilet had not been replaced.
July 22, 2016
Rated 4.0 out of 5.0 by DaisyChain 1960s 5 inch flange
Had a 1960s house that had a very large diameter toilet flange around 5 inches at around finished floor height and standard modern rings were to small in diameter and would fall halfway in hole and or raise toilet height if not modified perfectly. Used this product 3rd time changed toilet seal and sealed it and mounted well. Can't speak on the longevity had move after 6 months. But was easy to install and it fit that specific toilet situation.
September 25, 2016
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by BJ I will only use this product!
I installed this product, 5-years ago, on 2 of my American Standard toilets with no issues, what so ever. If you use a wax ring and don't get it perfect first try and have to re-position it again; chances are it will leak and have to be replaced. You can reposition this gasket as often as it takes and you will get a perfect seal every time. We use toilet bowl cleaner as most households do and haven't seen any deterioration. I'll never go back to wax ring again.
September 22, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Jeremy short life
This is a great idea, but wrong materials. I had this installed on a new floor when in just two months time has degrated and will not seal on a new floor flange and new toilet. It almost seemed to permiate the actual seal and leak or weap from that. Not happy with this product when it was purchased to make life better not harder.
September 6, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Calvin The worse toilet seal ever.
This toilet gasket waxless seal suppose to be easy to install and no leak but after 2 hour of install and re-install it still leak. I end up picked up a wax toilet seal that cost haft the price and it worked perfectly. I replaced toilet seal many many time before and this is by far the worse I have ever used. Don't buy this if you don't want to deal with any leak.
August 29, 2016
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by bc95 Unbelievable how great they work
I have always used the traditional wax rings but never again . No mess at all and use them just like any other only better the ring is soft and seals around the pipe and the base of the stool. You can avoid using any caulk around the bottom of the stool as these will not leak . No more dirty caulk no more removing the dirty caulk and re-caulking Love the green Ring
February 25, 2016