Hi Mandi,
Thank you for your review. I'm sorry to hear that your paint seems untinted. I recommend checking to see if the color was mixed correctly by comparing the paper swatch to the dried paint dab on the lid of your can. If they match up, the color is correct, and we recommend choosing a new color. You may want to purchase an 8 oz. sample of the new color to test out before making a larger purchase as well. If they don't match, the color may have been mixed incorrectly, and it's best to continue your project with the right color. So we can assist you with this further, please feel free to reach out to our Customer Care team directly. We hope to hear from you! - Sara