Pfister supports a lifetime warranty for most parts and defects. Please contact Pfister Consumer Service at 1-800-732-8238 for troubleshooting support and warranty replacement parts.
It could but is not designed to be reversible. The wee screw that tightens it would show on the top. Don't think this would be that noticeable if you touched it up with a sharpie, but that would be an individual call.
Model # BPH-YP1C mounting post base is 2 5/16" in diameter.