We purchased this during Home Depot's Black Friday sale, so the 5 stars is based on the price we paid, $1299. I would probably give it 4 stars if it was at the typical sale price of $1599, and wouldn't buy it at list price at all. But, this is the fridge I bought, at the price I paid, and I love it!
First, it is a solidly made refrigerator. It is the cousin to the Whirlpool WRX735SDBM (Whirlpool owns Amana). Fit, finish, size, everything is identical, except the deli drawer is internal to this fridge, and an external drawer on the Whirlpool. For our needs, the internal drawer is just fine, and is what we wanted. I can see where some people would like the external deli drawer.
Second, I like the separate ice and water dispensers. I don't like having to push a button to switch between ice and water. like most refrigerators have. Family who have the one leaver dispenser are always yelling that someone left the switch in the wrong setting.
Lastly, the freezer is very easy to use and adequately sized. We have no problem finding stuff in the freezer, and fitting what we need. If you have a large family and need to stock up on food, a larger fridge may be what you need, but I don't like the hulking super-size fridges I have seen which just invade the kitchen.
Now, the downsides. Some of the plastic edges aren't as smooth or finished as higher cost models. This is particularly noticeable on the crisper drawers. The shelves are adjustable only in about 1 inch increments, which is a little inconvenient since milk jugs and orange juice cartons either have to be tipped in to fit, or the shelf must be adjusted too high, wasting space. This is because all of the shelves, with the exception of the mini shelf which only fits next to the ice maker, are slide out, making them thicker than fixed shelves. This is a feature I don't find particularly useful.
I haven't experienced any issues as others have reported, such as noise or temperature inconsistency. The fridge works very well.
So, all that said, I am very happy and would buy again. I would recommend it to a friend if their needs were similar to mine.
Good Size & Weight, Easy to Use, Sturdy, Looks Great, Easy to Clean
some rough edges on plastic