I am only giving this 4 stars as we have only used it for just over a month. However, at this time I can say that it appears to be made VERY well and I expect that it will be with us for a very long time. So far we have used it to spread 3 cubic yards of soil and 6 cubic yards of wood chip mulch and it looks and performs just as good as when we started. Love the welding they've done on this rake. Definitely recommend other try it out. I'd rather pay a little more for a product that will last long-term than have to keep paying a little less multiple times because something keeps breaking.
Sturdy, works great for handling (sifting, spreading, taking apart, etc.) rocky and otherwise mixed soil, with no sign of giving up. It's even fun. Wouldn't recommend for very delicate work/narrow places, but no tool is going to be good for all uses. Wouldn't recommend it for picking your teeth or scratching your back either, but I didn't get it for those purposes.