Hello DOMINIC and thank you for the feedback you posted on the Home Depot website. Moen takes consumer comments very seriously and we are happy to have the opportunity to hear your opinion. We are sorry that the Moen Genta LX Pivoting Toilet Paper Holder in Brushed Nickel did not meet your expectations. As the original purchaser of the Moen Genta LX Pivoting Toilet Paper Holder in Brushed Nickel, you can contact Moen directly to review your concerns. Moen product specialists would be happy to work with you to find a satisfactory warranty resolution. They can be reached at 1-800-289-6636 and are available Monday through Friday from 8:00 am – 7:00 pm Eastern Time.