Rated 3.2 out of 5 by 109
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Lou Worked for me
People seem to love or hate this stuff. All I can say is that I am a novice who tiled my floor 24 hours ago, and it looks great and seems solid. I will give it more dry time because of the horror stories here. It didn't stick easily to concrete, which alarmed me at first. I picked up a small V-shaped trowel in the drywall section (don't know what it's called) and would recommend to other novices to use that to mash it down and spread it around, because the big trowel makes it curl up. (Then comb it once the area is covered.) It confused me that the tile company recommended 3/16" grout lines (I bought a 3/16" trowel) but the Simpleset tub recommended a larger trowel. I would have run this dilemma by the helpful tile staff at HD El Cerrito, but didn't notice it until after I was done.
August 7, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by JK Horrible. Don't waste your money.
Not at all suitable for a backsplash. It is too dry and therefore does not stick to the wall. I ended up with more on the floor than on the wall. I eventually gave up and yanked the tiles I had set off the wall. I'm going to try some of that adhesive tape stuff and see if it's any better. Will for sure be less mess. That's a bunch of money, time, and materials down the drain.
October 23, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by jus Don't buy this stuff
Watch this video before you do. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4i-hh_tD5U
I just wasted a day and a lot of money messing with this stuff. Ended up having to pull all the tile off of a bathroom install. One of the tiles fell damaging the tub, now I have to fix that.
Spent the better part of a day trying to lay 12x24" marble tiles. The ads and pictures give you the impression that you can work it with a trowel just like thin set that you mix. You cannot. It is like sticking wet sand to the wall. As soon as you try to drag a notched trowel through it 1/3 falls off the wall in to the tub. Then you try to replace that third and another third falls off. After laying down 3 courses I was so frustrated I quit and went to dinner. We decided to pull everything down and start over with real thin set. When we pulled the tiles down you could see that about 1/2 did not have any of this stuff stuck to anywhere but the corners. Fortunately it just scrapes right off so I should be able to use the tiles again. I would really like to have my money back.
September 5, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by Sara Still not set 96 hours after installing
Installed slate floor tiles on a bathroom floor on Wednesday, it's now Sunday and I can feel the tiles moving, squishing around underneath. Now after doing research, i'm finding that this is actually mastic with sand added, IT'S NOT MORTAR, does not fully dry, and is not appropriate for flooring, and is not water proof.
Does home depot offer refunds that will cover the slate tiles and cost of this tub of gooey trash? I can't believe this is even on store shelves
July 31, 2016
Rated 5.0 out of 5.0 by Zahra It held beautifully and there's easily saved leftovers, no mixing mess, and no clean-up. Do it yourself and no expensive contractors. Love it!
MUCH easier than the dry mix, no messy clean up of containers and stirring things. It applies perfectly and made my tile job a success. I was so nervous as I had heavy porcelain and Marble, but it worked perfectly. And I didn't have to use it all at once like the mix. I simply closed the lid and when I was ready to get back to tiling, it was ready. Loved It!
July 9, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by CJ Absolutely WORST product I've used
After 96 hrs still not dry. Started with level floor and perfect dry fit. Now have popping corners. Product coverage not correct and after 2 buckets of the junk had to finish job with the cheap stuff. Tiles set with the cheap stuff turned out perfect. Trashed $200 in tiles.
July 28, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by missinformed very disappointed!
this was recommended to me by an "experienced" home depot employee. seemed like a good product to use for my 1st time backsplash install. wrong! it wouldn't stay on the drywall. would not go on smoothly either. what i did get to stay on the wall wasn't holding up the tiles so i put some on the back of the tile and finallly got some to stick. let it stay there for about a week then decided it didn't look good, it looked lumpy and uneven. it hardened on the tiles but was still soft behind on the wall. decided to remove them & start over since the tiles looked so awful and that was a huge mistake. ripped new holes in the drywall & had to repair it again. all the tiles were ruined & had to buy some new stuff. talked with an employee at a different store & they advised against this using this product. so now, i will try again with another product that isn't premixed.
June 17, 2016
Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 by contractor bad batch
Both one gallon buckets of premixed Thinset were not useable when the buckets were opened as they had dried out in the bucket. Returned to the store for a refund
June 28, 2016