Hi there, thank you for your review. I'm sorry to hear you had this experience when using the Premium Plus Hi-Gloss Paint. That is not normal and certainly not the experience we want for our customers. Stirring the paint for 3-5 minutes to ensure all contents are mixed should result in a smooth, creamy consistency and should not be watery or appear thinned down. Nonetheless, your satisfaction is important to us, and we appreciate your feedback. Please reach out to us directly if you need further assistance. Our customer care team is happy to help you! - Randy