#1 Home Improvement Retailer

Customer Reviews for Malibu Wide Plank Monterey French Oak 3/4 in. T x 5 in. W Water Resistant Distressed Solid Hardwood Flooring (22.6 sq. ft./case)

Internet #303703108

Model #HDMSSTG513SF

Store SKU #1003112505

Customer Reviews

  • 4.5
    out of 147 reviews
  • 94% recommend this product
Filter by:
Showing 1-30 of 147 reviews
french oak miramar floor
Happy with color and quality of the floor. Random length is easy to install
by
    • Recommended
    Farm house style, beautiful floor
    Miramar color looks great! the floor solid and sturdy, not easy get scratched. i was struggled between Miramar and Point Reyes. But at the end, I chose Miramar. Miramar is lighter than Point Reyes, but Point Reyes' wood grain texture is more obvious with more yellow tone. For me, I like light color more. I will pick Light House next time.
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    • Recommended
    These floors turned out great. Definitely important to get your...
    These floors turned out great. Definitely important to get your first row very straight and square especially if you are continuing these floors into hallways or other rooms. High quality material, looks clean, modern and cozy. Already considering it for other rooms in the house!
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    It was very nice and seemed to be of very...
    It was very nice and seemed to be of very high quality however, we were told it would be 4 months before it would arrive so we returned the box we bought to set in the house. That is the way it is with todays supply chain issues.
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    We were thrilled with this product...well milled, great appearance....
    We were thrilled with this product...well milled, great appearance.
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    The review is for Malibu Wide Plank French Oak Point...
    The review is for Malibu Wide Plank French Oak Point Reyes 3/4 in. Thick x 5 in. wide. I have not install floors yet but I have opened few boxes and I love the quality of the wood and warm color with nice variation of boards. It looks much better than online. We wanted something lighter to brighten up the living room and durable.There were zero damaged planks the cases that I have opened. It is a very beautiful matte finish so won't show dust and footprints.
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    I absolutely love my new floor and my new house....
    I absolutely love my new floor and my new house. I spent over a hundred hours looking at flooring before picking this. French oak. It is a very beautiful matte finish so won't show dust and footprints. The product was excellent with only one board with screwed up edges out 1400 square feet installed. The gentleman installing the wood said it was very good product. Only complaint is we wished there was a few more long boards in the packs .
    by
    Response from MWP_PRODUCT EXPERTMay 20, 2022
    We are excited you love your floor. This 3/4" Solid Flooring has random lengths up to 59 in. JasonMWP
    • Verified Purchase
    The wood planks were milled perfectly. Not a single...
    The wood planks were milled perfectly. Not a single tongue and groove imperfection. Floor looks great
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    Great quality Wood Flooring. Fell in love as soon...
    Great quality Wood Flooring. Fell in love as soon as I saw it installed. I just got the playroom done and now I can't wait to get my Main Living room done. I purchased the Pointe Reyes and is great.
    by
    • Verified Purchase
    High Quality Product
    This is a very high quality flooring with nearly 100% usable planking. Overall great look and very durable outcome. I've installed solid wood flooring before - this is the best. Highly recommend!
    by
      • Recommended
      very happy with the quality of the flooring...
      very happy with the quality of the flooring
      by
        The surface treatment was not as good as what I...
        The surface treatment was not as good as what I purchased 5 months ago.
        by
          GREAT thick solid floor!
          its a SOLID 3/4 of an inch good quality solid wood floor that with a good care will probably last for many many years.
          by
            • Recommended
            Top coating was not as smooth as what I got...
            Top coating was not as smooth as what I got last time.
            by
            Response from MWP_PRODUCT EXPERTJan 5, 2022
            Malibu Wide Plank Reclaimed Solid Hardwood Series is created using special tools to add authentic distress to wood surfaces, with unique and subtle designed straight saw marks captivating the eye, while hand-rolled edges and ends further heighten the visual appeal. Completed with 7 coats of ultra-low-gloss urethane finish with aluminum oxide, these floors are created to last, and to love, for a lifetime. JasonMWP
              Excellent!
              Great flooring and I love the finish - is very durable! I installed 65 boxes - it goes down quick with the wide boards - I prefer staples over cleats but recommend gluing every tongue on the long and short end to eliminate squeaks. Great purchase!
              by
                • Recommended
                by
                  Love this flooring. Transformed my home.
                  Love this flooring. Transformed my home.
                  by
                    • Recommended
                    I put this flooring on our main floor two years...
                    I put this flooring on our main floor two years ago and it still looks amazing. Did the stairs and second floor this time. Great quality and had no waste issues in either installation.
                    by
                    • Verified Purchase
                    Solid and nice look
                    Good quality flooring. Thicker plank solid feel. Contemporary look.
                    by
                      • Recommended
                      Great stuf. Easy install, as long as you have a...
                      Great stuf. Easy install, as long as you have a floor nailer. Love the flat finish.
                      by
                      • Verified Purchase
                      Great flooring that I highly recommend....
                      Great flooring that I highly recommend.
                      by
                      • Verified Purchase
                      Rating provided by a verified purchaser...
                      Rating provided by a verified purchaser
                      by
                      • Verified Purchase
                      Despite the packaging that is 7 feet long, almost the...
                      Despite the packaging that is 7 feet long, almost the totality of the boards are very short (between 1 and 2 feet) . There is only one board in each package with a length between 3 and 4 feet. Very disappointing for a flooring product that has a cost of more than $6/SF with the advertise mentioning that the product has a good amount of long boards. That is not the case at all. I should be entitle for a refund to balance the value of this lower grade product I have received. Pls advise
                      by
                      Response from MWP_PRODUCT EXPERTApr 21, 2021
                      The Malibu Wide Plank 3/4" Thick x 5" Wide Solid Hardwood Flooring comes in random/varying lengths up to 59", the Solid Collections do not state a minimum % of Full Length planks in each case like most Malibu Engineered Hardwood collections do. The French Oak raw lumber that is used to mill the product is harvested in Europe, primarily France or Germany. This gorgeous French Oak lumber has tannins unique to the species, which allow the staining process to offer greater color depth than standard Oak flooring offers. The gorgeous reclaimed wire brushed surface texture combined with the UV low gloss factory finish, make this an excellent Solid Hardwood Flooring choice for your residential or commercial installation. If you review the French Oak 3/4" Solid Hardwood Room Scene pictures and all digital assets, you can view all black filler used for stability in this handcrafted character grade floor which uses ABCD grade French Oak Lumber. We use character grade hardwood to meet these design specifications, which may include naturally occurring cracks, splits, knotholes, mineral streaks, filler for stability, etc. By using this grade of material we are able to enhance the natural beauty of the hardwood floor you have chosen. We highly suggest reviewing all room scenes, digital assets, reviewing store samples if available, and always order online samples available for purchase. For assistance and troubleshooting please call our Home Depot Technical Services department @ 800-928-6168 or customer service department at 650-416-7300. JasonMWP
                      • Verified Purchase
                      3 found this review helpful
                      We absolutely love our Malibu Wide Plank French Oak Point...
                      We absolutely love our Malibu Wide Plank French Oak Point Reys hardwood floors. We did our whole first floor and have a lot left so we’ll go on to the second floor too! We like that the knots are filled with black resin that gives it nice character yet still a very clean lite modern space.
                      by
                      • Verified Purchase
                      The flooring was awesome! The install was smooth and the...
                      The flooring was awesome! The install was smooth and the new look of the house is Amazing
                      by
                      • Verified Purchase
                      The hardwood is beautiful and was pretty easy to install....
                      The hardwood is beautiful and was pretty easy to install. Mill quality of the wood is very good and there were very few pieces in over 1400 sq feet that had any issues. One thing that did frustrate was the sizes packed in the boxes. They were not very random, and we quickly found we had only two different packing variations. Check the lot numbers on the box and mix them up for best results.
                      by
                      Response from MWP_PRODUCT EXPERTMar 18, 2021
                      During installation process its always recommended to follow detailed instructions in the Installation guide located under info & Guides on each product listing page, recommended is working and installing planks out of numerous cartons and mixing to ensure good color and grain variation. For assistance and troubleshooting please call our Home Depot Technical Services department @ 800-928-6168 or customer service department at 650-416-7300. JasonMWP
                      • Verified Purchase
                      2 found this review helpful
                      The product installed easily and looks great!...
                      The product installed easily and looks great!
                      by
                      • Verified Purchase
                      Nice flooring. This finish is very close to a...
                      Nice flooring. This finish is very close to a clear natural color of the wood; it has no perceptible tint. The rough texture is very nice. The only thing to be aware of is that all surface patches (and there are quite a few) are done using a black resin. It work alright with this color as they tend to look like knots, but some people might find them too obtrusive. I like them because fixing future small damage spots will be very easy if required (just fill with black resin!)
                      by
                      Response from MWP_PRODUCT EXPERTMar 18, 2021
                      We are excited you love your floor. If you review the French Oak 3/4" Solid Hardwood Room Scene pictures and all digital assets, you can view all black filler used for stability in this handcrafted character grade floor which uses ABCD grade French Oak Lumber. We use character grade hardwood to meet these design specifications, which may include naturally occurring cracks, splits, knotholes, mineral streaks, black filler for stability, etc. By using this grade of material we are able to enhance the natural beauty of the hardwood floor you have chosen. We highly suggest reviewing all room scenes, digital assets, reviewing store samples if available, and always order online samples available for purchase. For assistance and troubleshooting please call our Home Depot Technical Services department @ 800-928-6168 or customer service department at 650-416-7300. JasonMWP
                      • Verified Purchase
                      Gorgeous, looked just like the sample. The quality was fantastic...
                      Gorgeous, looked just like the sample. The quality was fantastic for an inexpensive hardwood.
                      by
                      • Verified Purchase
                      Showing 1-30 of 147 reviews

                      Frequently Bought Together

                      Top Rated
                      +
                      +
                      Price:
                      $159.25

                      Compare Similar Items

                      current item

                      Finish Type

                      Prefinished

                      Prefinished

                      Prefinished

                      Prefinished

                      Installation Location

                      Above Grade/Wood Subfloor

                      Above Grade/Wood Subfloor

                      Above Grade/Wood Subfloor

                      Above Grade/Wood Subfloor

                      Plank Width

                      Narrow plank (5 in or less)

                      Narrow plank (5 in or less)

                      Narrow plank (5 in or less)

                      Narrow plank (5 in or less)

                      Installation Method

                      Nail Down

                      Nail Down

                      Nail Down

                      Nail Down

                      Hardwood Floor Features

                      Dent Resistant, Scratch Resistant, Supports Refinishing

                      Dent Resistant, Scratch Resistant, Supports Refinishing

                      Dent Resistant, Scratch Resistant, Supports Refinishing

                      No Additional Features