Hello - we're very sorry to hear that both of your freezers did not work out for you. We know that having a working freezer is important, and we completely understand your disappointment. -- We always strive to make products with the highest quality possible, so we will make sure that the appropriate teams are aware of these concerns regarding the lid of the freezer for future design consideration. -- Please let us know if any other questions or concerns come up. Have a great one. - Pablo@GEA