Hi Cindy, thanks for your review. I'm sorry to hear you didn't get the finish you expected with our Cabinet, Door & Trim paint. It sounds like the paint may still be in the curing process since you mentioned it comes off easily with your fingernail. To fix this, I recommend gently cleaning the surface to remove any dirt and loose paint. Then, you can apply another coat while maintaining a wet edge to get an even finish. Allow the new coat to fully cure and harden before trying to clean or scratch it. Customer satisfaction is very important to us, so feel free to reach out to our Customer Care team directly for further assistance. They are always happy to help. Enjoy the rest of your day. -Christina