Hello Rcg4008, Thank you for your review on our HDX 27 Gallon Tough Tote in Black/Yellow. We are sorry to hear of your experience using a 36 Gallon storage tote, however, The HDX family does not have a 36 gallon size in Black/Yellow. We do have a family that includes a 27gal and 38gal. If you have one of these storage totes with a broken lid please contact our Customer Care team at (888) 511-3013 and someone will be happy to assist you. Thank you for shopping at The Home Depot!