Hello Chris, we're sorry to hear you weren't satisfied with our Calacatta White color. We understand how frustrating that can be! We do offer free samples of the material that can be requested at our website to help with the color selection process (see https://flexstoneproducts.com/request-samples/ ). For returns, you'll need to work with Home Depot, but if you'd like to reorder in another color we'd be happy to send out some samples of some of our other colors for you. Please let us know if you have any questions.