The following is just my opinion based on my experience with four of these legs:
I made my wife a new maple table for our anniversary, but since I don't have a lathe to turn legs I ordered these. They are only available in pine, not maple but since that part of the table was going to be painted, I decided it would be okay. They took about a week and a half to arrive and were not packed well. All four were bundled tightly with cellophane wrap but were mailed in an over-sized box with no padding whatsoever. They were free to fly around in the box and apparently did with some minor chips and dings that I repaired. Despite the "butcher block" name the legs are not turned from solid pine, but from (in my case) 3 to 5 boards glued together. This would be okay, but several were already starting to separate along the glue seam. I filled in with some wood glue and hoped for the best. The table is finished now and looks beautiful (imho). I am not worried about the solid maple top or the solid maple skirt, but I am somewhat concerned about the longevity of the pine legs over the years and whether humidity and temperature changes will again cause them to start to separate.
Pros: Looks Great, Functional, Nice Design
Cons: poorly glued