Hello AJ, we appreciate you sharing your feedback. We're sorry to hear your paint's finishing color didn't turn out as expected; that's not the experience we want our customers to have with our products. To verify that your color was mixed correctly, we’d suggest checking that the physical color swatch matches the paint dab on the lid of your can. If the colors match, the paint was properly mixed, and the color is correct. In cases like this, the best solution would be to recoat in a different color. If the swatch doesn’t match the dab on your can’s lid, the color was incorrectly mixed and we’d suggest recoating with new paint tinted to the correct color. Please keep in mind that different lighting will affect how a color looks and that our online color palette display may vary slightly from the actual colors due to variances in monitor settings. So, we’d recommend picking up a sample of the color and applying it first before purchasing new paint to ensure you’re getting the right color for the area you’re planning on painting. Customer satisfaction is important to us. Please feel free to reach out to our Customer Care team directly for additional assistance or if you have any questions. Have a great rest of your day. –Joanna