Hi Craig, thanks for your review. I'm sorry to hear the paint seemed too thin and didn't cover. This isn't normal, as our paint should have the consistency of a blended smoothie. If the paint is watery and stirring for several minutes doesn't help, I don't recommend using it. Customer satisfaction is very important to us, so feel free to reach out to our Customer Care team directly for further assistance. They are always happy to help. Enjoy the rest of your day. -Christina