#1 Home Improvement Retailer

Customer Reviews for KEENEY 4 in. Stainless Steel Garbage Disposal Flange and Stopper in Black

Internet #204374085

Model #K5417BLK

Store SKU #1000537272

  • Durable stainless steel construction for long-lasting use
  • Easy-to-grab knob offers easy handling
  • Designed for GE, ISE, Kenmore, and Kitchen Aid units

Customer Reviews

  • 4.2
    out of 25 reviews
  • 67% recommend this product
Filter by:
Showing 1-25 of 25 reviews
looks great but..
only lasted 1 year before it started chipping.. find a different one!
by
    The matte black finish started chipping off soon after installation.
    The matte black finish started chipping off soon after installation.
    by
    Response from Keeney Customer SupportJun 16, 2021
    We are sorry to hear about this product issue. Keeney understands how disappointing this can be for you. Thank you for taking the time to express your concerns with this product.
    If you have any further questions/concerns, please do not hesitate to contact: ksupport@oatey.com. PlumbPak
      Perfect fit for 3½" sink opening. Looks great with my...
      Perfect fit for 3½" sink opening. Looks great with my black sink.
      by
      • Verified Purchase
      Paint peeled
      Pain peeled off after a few months, poor quality. Have had for 3 years, hasn't rusted so the stainless is decent quality at least. Look for a chemically coated flange instead of a painted one.
      by
      Response from OateyJan 9, 2024
      Thank you for writing a review. We realize your experience with our product has been less than ideal and we would like to have the opportunity to change that, as quality is a top priority at Oatey. If you are still having issues with this product, please reach out to us directly at technical@oatey.com so that we can help. Oatey
        by
        • Verified Purchase
        by
          by
          • Verified Purchase
          These last for about a year, then the copper/brass shows...
          These last for about a year, then the copper/brass shows through the powder coat. They're a hassle. I keep replacing them because we have a black sink that we both love. Wish they'd do better with their coatings; there's only the two of us, we certainly wouldn't qualify as "hard use".
          by
          Response from Keeney Customer SupportJun 16, 2021
          We are sorry to hear about this product issue. Keeney understands how disappointing this can be for you. Thank you for taking the time to express your concerns with this product.
          If you have any further questions/concerns, please do not hesitate to contact: ksupport@oatey.com. PlumbPak
          • Verified Purchase
          1 found this review helpful
          Fit perfect, nice finish and fully adaptable
          Fit perfect, nice finish and fully adaptable
          by
          • Verified Purchase
          • Recommended
          Nice finish quality product...
          Nice finish quality product
          by
          • Verified Purchase
          Rating provided by a verified purchaser...
          Rating provided by a verified purchaser
          by
          • Verified Purchase
          Great replacement garbage disposal flange. Added plus doesn't have any...
          Great replacement garbage disposal flange. Added plus doesn't have any advertisment on the exposed edge.
          by
          • Verified Purchase
          Worked great!...
          Worked great!
          by
          • Verified Purchase
          Does not fit GE disposals
          The description online lists this as GE compatible, but when it arrived, the packaging does not list GE. I tried it install to see and sure enough, this will NOT work with GE disposals. Ended up spray painting my old flange black and it looks great. Someone needs to correct the online description.
          by
            1 found this review helpful
            Fit well. Installed easy. Black on black sink is...
            Fit well. Installed easy. Black on black sink is great.
            by
            • Verified Purchase
            The assembly was as expected, and matched my sink perfectly....
            The assembly was as expected, and matched my sink perfectly.
            by
            • Verified Purchase
            Good
            Good
            by
            • Verified Purchase
            • Recommended
            This was perfect! It goes so well with our black sink! I'm very happy...
            This was perfect! It goes so well with our black sink! I'm very happy...
            by
            • Verified Purchase
            • Recommended
            Holds water in with no leaking....
            Holds water in with no leaking.
            by
            • Verified Purchase
            really wanted a black flange for my new black sink....
            really wanted a black flange for my new black sink. this one worked great with my insinkerator disposal and was about half the price of the insinkerator brand.
            by
            • Verified Purchase
            Solid so far
            Looks great. Matched our black faucet. No issues after a month so far.
            by
              • Recommended
              Excellent. Fits garbage disposal just right and keeps water in the sink. I would recommend.
              Excellent. Fits garbage disposal just right and keeps water in the sink. I would recommend.
              by
              • Verified Purchase
              • Recommended
              2 found this review helpful
              Perfect Black Disposal Flange
              Appears to be a quality product. Installation was as expected. The color matches the Pegasus granite composite sink perfectly.
              by
              • DIY
              • Verified Purchase
              • Recommended
              Great product at a great price
              I am very pleased with this replacement garbage disposal flange. I was worried because many other manufacturer's products that were similar got bad reviews saying that the black paint chipped off the flange and they could see the metal underneath that was not black. Well, so far that has not happened here. Also, the price of this one was cheap. But I figured if it did chip, I would be less annoyed that I only paid $15, where as others I saw were upwards of $40.
              by
              • Verified Purchase
              • Recommended
              1 found this review helpful
              Great Flange
              This flange was exactly what I needed to replace the old one that was falling apart after 3 yrs. This on e matched better and seems to be stronger at a better price than any one else offered.
              by
              • Verified Purchase
              • Recommended
              2 found this review helpful
              Showing 1-25 of 25 reviews

              Frequently Bought Together

              +
              +
              Price:
              $14.39