Customer Reviews for DECKMATE #9 2-1/2 in. Tan Exterior Self-Starting Star Flat-Head Wood Deck Screw (5 lbs./435-Pieces)

I built a 10x20 deck last fall. Laid it out with HD deck designer and picked up everything at my local store. These "NEW and improved" design deck mate screws are the worst fastener I've ever used. I had no problem with them tightening down like other people have claimed. My issue showed up 4 months later. After the snow melted I inspected the deck and found a few screw heads sticking up. Well to my surprise when I went to tighten them down I found all of them had broke!!! Now I'm in the process of replacing all the deckmate screws with GRK. So far 50% of them are broken. Stay far away from these screws!! Im going to contact my local HD and demand my Money back

“Improved” version absolutely sucks. It’s horrible, does not pull the two pieces of wood together. The screw just keeps spinning. Bring back the old version, which was perfect!!! If you want to pre-drill every hole, buy it, otherwise look at other brands. I am so disappointed as I bought a lot of them and I used to rave about this screw using it for everything outdoors and indoors. Picture shows “improved” version on left, with different thread pattern that does not create a tight connection anymore

The only Deck Screws I use. Love them....

Rating provided by a verified purchaser

Product I received is not like the picture. It doesn't have clear smooth threads.Anchor failure results from the additional cutting surfaces incorporated into and between the ordinary screw-ridges. These seem to be popular right now, but they have the result of turning the fastener into more of a drill bit and less of a fastener. Most of these have no significant holding power as a result of having bored out what should have been a tight anchor hole. I am unable to use them and would like to return them for refund but the nearest HD store is an hour away - my son picked them up for me. A waste of money. If I could find the old, smooth deck screws somewhere, I would buy 25 lbs of each size. See my photo of one of these screws. If HD is going to sell these, they REALLY should update the picture so as not to mislead people like me!

My deck is 17 years old and I have had to remove the cedar deck boards twice to access drainage issues under the deck. I used Deckmate screws both times and am glad I did. On both occasions I was able to remove the screws without any issues! Attached are a couple of photos of some of the screws that I just removed after 7 years of use. I wouldn't hesitate to reuse them but I'm installing a Trex deck to avoid the annual maintenance of a cedar deck. Great product Deckmate!

This is a great screw I have used it to build two shops and a treated pine deck has great grip

I really like the new star drive instead of the old Phillips heads. These go in quickly and pretty effortlessly. I went thru over 15 lbs of these on my project. I used them to attach around 500 balusters to my deck railing.

Good quality easy to use

These screw go into wood and hold pieces of wood together. I used them on my deck and installed them with a drill driver. They are deck colored.

Easy to use. Came w/ star bit. Like the tan color option.

Screws work as expected. Very easy to screw deck boards down. Even for a newbie like me.

Screws were easy to use.

Work exactly as described / advertised.

Rating provided by a verified purchaser

Excellent deck screw.

The brand everyone knows and I know why. Great grip, easy to use. The only deck screws I would use.

Poor quality control. too much coating in bit receptacle.

These screws worked great on the deck I was working on .

Hope these work better than regular wood or outdoor screws. Sink very easily. Quite a few were unusable due to the fact that the star was obstructed with existing paint and metal. Nice that they give a new star but for every box.

These were very easy to install and were the best decking screws I have ever used.

First one had som problem whith tha chock soo need to be replaced it second one is better work good Ridge life time warranty is worst then trash they don’t won’t to repair my power i tools I’m register on line rhight after I got then but Homedepot tools rental Deparment don’t want to do anything I which they replaced no one help tha is not professional Homedepot image goin down I which som one call me them I will tell you end you will anderstnd me if you care meke the different thanks you

Rating provided by a verified purchaser

Couple of the screws snapped when a board warped

Rating provided by a verified purchaser